I received word this week that the "Dateline" episode this Memorial Day Weekend, on Sunday 25 May at 7pm EDT, will address the guilt that many soldiers experience after killing (justly) in war.
Dateline came by my office last October and filmed an interview. I hope that the show will raise awareness on the issue. A big first step to helping our soldiers make sense of their experience of killing in war is breaking the taboo and becoming more honest about the moral reality of war. A second necessary step is having a shared vocabulary that enables soldiers and citizens to talk about the wrestle through the concepts and experiences. Traditional Just War Theory is woefully in adequate in addressing the moral issues of individual killing. Hopefully my writing has contributed to both goals. More needs to be done. I invite you to join the discussion and the cause.
I am a retired Army officer who believes in the moral standing of the profession of arms, yet recognizes its shortcomings. I served in the Army from 1984-2017, mostly in the infantry and on the faculty at West Point. As a researcher of combat leadership and ethics, I interviewed hundreds of Army leaders in Iraq and Afghanistan between 2003-2011. Welcome to this online space for thinking about war, morality, and the profession of arms. Follow me @combat_ethics
War can be an Experience of both Heaven and Hell
Many combat veterans have a love/hate relationship with their wartime experiences. They love the profound sense of purpose that their liv...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
This is my latest version of laying out the argument. Feedback is welcomed! A moral justification for killing in war By Pete Kilner, 2009 In...
-
Among my statements that were included in the film "Soldiers of Conscience," my thought experiment about the Good Samaritan has ev...
-
Killing in War: a Rights-based Justification Why killing enemy combatants is morally justified BLUF: When we kill enemy combatants, we are n...
-
I posted this on the POV.org blog in response to viewers of Soldiers of Conscience praising the featured conscientious objectors' courag...
-
Life is funny. On the day that I leave my regular work (at a desk) and begin the process of deploying to Afghanistan, the BBC runs an artic...
3 comments:
Pete, I am a retired Air Force chief now engaged in, among other things, spiritual direction. I watched your segment on Dateline, and it immediately hit home. Although I have never killed anyone, I recognized the truth when I heard it.
The segment began to coalesce some thoughts I had rolling around in my mind concerning how to help military members suffering from the trauma they've encountered in war. I would like to share them with you in a media other than this. you can reach me at jtschida1@earthlink.net.
Thanks.
Jeff Tschida
Pete, I came across your blog while doing research for my thesis on just war theory and have enjoyed reading it. I was wondering if you still teach PY201 at West Point. I'd be interested in knowing more about the syllabus. From what I can gather just war theory is a very important feature of the class. I'd really appreciate it if you got in touch so we could talk a little more.
Sorry, forgot my e-mail address: chug02 (at) gmail.com
Post a Comment