Refuting some bad assumptions about morality and war

As a military ethicist who strives to engage in constructive conversations about the morality of war, I’ve come to recognize five common misconceptions that sabotage efforts to think critically about morality and war. The mistaken assumptions undermine any realistic possibility of a war being morally justified. Therefore, the misconceptions must be addressed and debunked to set the conditions for meaningful discussions.

The five misconceptions are:

  1. Peace is always an option.
  2. Both sides in war are always wrong.
  3. Warfighting is analogous morally to a sports competition.
  4. Motives must be pure for a war to be just.
  5. Any immoral acts in a war make the entire war immoral.
I invite you to read the entire article and share your thoughts.

Think deeply. Act justly.


No comments:

The Military Leader’s Role in Mitigating Moral Injury

War is a breeding ground for moral injury. Even in a justified [1] war that is fought justly, combat soldiers are likely to intentional...